By Greek yogurt might just be my favorite ingredient for making desserts that are actually delicious and packed with protein. One cup of plain nonfat Greek yogurt from the right brand can have over 25 grams of protein - and it adds this uber-creamy, tangy richness that makes desserts taste better, not "healthy."
Want to save this recipe?
Enter your email below & we'll send it straight to your inbox. Plus you'll get fun new recipes from us every week!
As a NASM-certified nutrition coach, I'm all about getting protein from whole food ingredients rather than powders. And Greek yogurt is one of the best tools I have. Whether it's replacing cream cheese in a cheesecake or adding moisture to a cookie, it shows up in so many of our favorite high-protein dessert recipes for good reason!
Jump to:
Why Greek Yogurt is Great for Desserts
Greek yogurt does a lot of heavy lifting in dessert recipes. It adds moisture to baked goods, creates an uber-creamy texture in no-bake desserts (replacing heavy cream, sour cream, or cream cheese), and boosts protein without compromising flavor. The slight tang actually enhances sweet recipes because it pairs so well with honey, chocolate, peanut butter, and fruit.
If you've made any of our Greek yogurt breakfast recipes or Greek yogurt dinner recipes, you already know how great it is. Dessert is where it really shines, though.
No-Bake Greek Yogurt Desserts
These are the easy recipes that require minimal effort but produce maximum flavor and protein. Great for warmer days when you don't feel like turning on the oven.
1. Strawberry Greek Yogurt Icebox Cake
339 cal · 8g protein per slice
It took a few rounds of testing to get this one right, not gonna lie. I wanted something that felt like a summer dessert without being overly sweet or soggy. The final version layers Greek yogurt, fresh strawberries, and graham crackers into a no-bake cake that's fruity, creamy, and so, so refreshing!
2. High-Protein Banana Pudding
532 cal · 18g protein per serving
Ok, I kid you not that this might be my favorite way to eat bananas. It's ready in 10 minutes, there's no condensed milk, and Greek yogurt does all the creamy heavy lifting. And yes, I use graham crackers instead of vanilla wafers. I said what I said. If you have leftover bananas after making this, our banana protein cake is the perfect next move.
3. Healthier Peanut Butter Truffles
134 cal · 6g protein per truffle
Chocolate-coated, creamy peanut butter filling, 134 calories. That's it. That's the pitch. The inside is Greek yogurt mixed with peanut butter powder, and they keep in the fridge for up to two weeks, BUT I doubt they'll last that long, ha!
4. Chocolate Protein Fudge
130 cal · 4g protein per square
Two. Main. Ingredients. Dark chocolate and Greek yogurt. I tested this many times. But the final version? Perfectly creamy and smooth. Store it in the fridge and you'll have a protein-packed treat for the week.
5. High-Protein Dunkaroo Dip
398 cal · 16g protein per serving
The nostalgia is real with this one. If you grew up on Dunkaroos, this is going to bring it all back. I tested this every which way but there's no replicating that flavor without a little confetti frosting. Mixed with Greek yogurt and cottage cheese, it's packed with protein. Grab some crackers and go to town!
6. Brownie Batter Yogurt Parfait
318 cal · 6g protein per serving
Fun fact: I'm not really into parfaits. So I challenged myself to make one I'd actually want to eat. Fast-forward to eating this twice in two days, and I think I was successful! Chocolate yogurt layered with raspberries and granola - it's ready in 5 minutes and easily made dairy-free with Siggi's yogurt.
7. S'mores Yogurt Parfait
631 cal · 25g protein per serving
Okay I admit I went a little crazy with this one. With chocolate syrup and marshmallow fluff, it's like a taste of summer without the smoky bonfire! You could eat this s'mores parfait in two servings because it's a bit high in calories, but it's very difficult to not eat it all. 😎
8. High Protein Chocolate Chia Seed Pudding
423 cal · 18g protein per serving
This recipe can be a bit confusing because I can't decide if it's breakfast or dessert. What do you think? I'll let you decide.. Five minutes of work, then the fridge handles the rest overnight. Greek yogurt makes this extra thick (no runny chia pudding here), and the cocoa powder gives it a brownie batter vibe. Yum!
Baked Greek Yogurt Desserts
Greek yogurt keeps baked goods super moist and tender while adding protein, and these recipes prove it!
9. Cheesecake Without Cream Cheese
340 cal · 15g protein per slice
This is one of our most popular recipes on the entire site. Five ingredients. No cream cheese. Greek yogurt does everything here making filling creamy, smooth, and giving it 15g of protein per slice. It's the recipe I point people to who say "Greek yogurt can't be a dessert." Oh, but it can.
10. Chocolate Brownies with Pumpkin
250 cal · 8g protein per square
Before you scroll past this one.. no, you can't taste the pumpkin. It just makes the brownies extra fudgy and tender! Greek yogurt handles the moisture, pumpkin adds fiber, and the result is a rich, chocolatey brownie with 8g of protein that nobody will suspect is secretly good for them.
11. Protein Carrot Cake
482 cal · 15g protein per slice
Carrot cake is my love language. This one has warm, punchy flavors from ginger and cardamom (not just the usual cinnamon), a tangy cream cheese frosting made with high-protein goat cheese, and it's all done in one bowl. It can easily be made gluten-free, too. At 15g of protein per slice, there's zero guilt in going back for seconds!
12. Banana Protein Cake
262 cal · 10g protein per slice
Greek yogurt + hemp seeds + ripe bananas = a super moist cake at just 262 calories per slice. One thing I learned the hard way on my first test: cover it with foil toward the end. The yogurt reacts with the baking soda and the top browns fast. Other than that one trick, it couldn't be easier.
13. Protein Apple Cake Without Protein Powder
416 cal · 13g protein per slice
We use both shredded and diced apples here to infuse flavor into every single bite. Greek yogurt is used in both the batter and the frosting on this one so you get a double dose of creamy protein! The whole thing stores well in the fridge for up to a week, just warm it up for 15 seconds in the microwave and it tastes fresh baked.
14. Protein Pancake Coffee Cake
430 cal · 18g protein per slice
I don't mean to brag, but this coffee cake rivals any bakery version I've had. Our protein pancake batter goes into a cake pan with a cinnamon sugar layer and the most delicious crumb topping. And here's the results: 18g of protein, half the sugar of traditional coffee cake, and all of it comes from natural sweeteners!
15. Pumpkin Protein Cheesecake Bites
463 cal · 15g protein per square
I make these for fall get togethers and no one has any idea they're high protein and have a Greek yogurt base. They're super easy to whip up and keep in the fridge. Just pull them out after dinner and you have an instant dessert spread.
16. Protein Strawberry Shortcake
325 cal · 15g protein per serving
Five ingredients. Ten minutes. That's the whole elevator pitch. The shortcakes are basically protein drop biscuits made with pancake mix and Greek yogurt, and they come out fluffy and golden. Add fresh strawberries and Cool Whip and it's summer on a plate! I keep a stash of the biscuits in the freezer so I'm always ready.
17. Baked Apple Cider Donut Holes
190 cal · 5g protein per 2 bites
These donut holes are baked, not fried. They're also rolled in cinnamon sugar and made with, you guessed it, Greek yogurt, which makes them SO tender and reasonable calories. These are the fall treat I never know I needed. They go down fast so I recommend a double batch!
18. Greek Yogurt Donuts
187 cal · 6g protein per donut
As a self-proclaimed donut connoisseur, these Greek yogurt donuts are most definitely up to snuff! They're filled with raspberries and topped with a lemon sugar coating so are bursting with flavor. They pack in 6g of protein each without protein powder and are ready in just 20 minutes, thanks to the air fryer (so no deep frying!).
Greek Yogurt Cookies & Bars
Yes, you can make cookies with Greek yogurt. And yes, they come out soft, chewy, and packed with protein!
18. Gluten-Free Protein Chocolate Chip Cookies
374 cal · 11g protein per cookie
These protein chocolate chip cookies get their 11g of protein from all whole, real ingredients (hi, Greek yogurt!). But, they aren't cakey or dry like most protein cookies; this one is chewy with crisp edges - honestly, they belong in a bakery case. 😎 No powders and no chalky aftertaste!
19. Almond Flour Cocoa Cookies
205 cal · 6g protein per cookie
If you refuse to settle for one type of chocolate, like I often do, these have both cocoa powder AND chocolate chunks. Yum! They're fudgy, gluten-free, and Greek yogurt keeps them oh so moist without making them cakey.
20. High Protein Cinnamon Roll Bites
268 cal · 10g protein per serving (8 bites)
When you want a cinnamon roll but you're too lazy to bake a whole tray, these cinnamon roll bites are the next best thing! They take 30 minutes total and bake right in the meal prep container you can store them in after (assuming it's glass, don't use plastic - ha!).
Chilled Greek Yogurt Desserts
21. Frozen Yogurt S'mores Clusters
349 cal · 6g protein per 2 clusters
Think of these as the grab-and-go version of the s'mores parfait above. Greek yogurt, marshmallows, graham crackers, and chocolate is frozen into little clusters. Our kiddo is obsessed with these, and honestly, so am I. Just pull a couple from the freezer whenever you need something sweet.
22. Caramel Apple Yogurt Bark
170 cal · 6g protein per serving
This one comes together in about 5 minutes of hands-on time. Spread Greek yogurt on a tray, scatter chopped apples and pretzels on top, drizzle with caramel, and freeze. Once it's set, just snap it into pieces. The sweet-salty-tangy combo here is so good, and it's become one of our go-to fall treats!
23. Greek Yogurt Key Lime Pie
258 cal · 8g protein per serving
Full disclosure - key lime pie has been my favorite dessert since a high school trip to the Florida Keys, so I'm a little picky about this one. After many rounds of testing, this version uses honey instead of condensed milk, and the tang from the Greek yogurt paired with fresh lime juice is perfection. I make these in mini pie crusts and stash them in the freezer for months so I always have one within reach.
24. Apple Snickers Salad
436 cal · 25g protein per serving
This one might sound a little out there, but trust me when I say that chopped apples, chocolate chips, and Greek yogurt tossed together make an incredibly delicious, crunchy, chilled salad-dessert thing. It's one of those recipes that you try once because you're curious and then make again because it's TOTALLY addictive. And 25g of protein? For a dessert? I'll take it!
Tips for Using Greek Yogurt in Desserts
After developing dozens of dessert recipes with Greek yogurt, here are my top tips:
- Use plain, non-fat Greek yogurt. I always get this because flavored yogurts add unwanted sugar and artificial flavors. You can keep sugar low and tweak the sweetness to your ideal level when you get plain yogurt.
- It can be swapped for sour cream in many baking recipes. The texture is similar and it Greek yogurt has a little more tang, but it brings way more protein!
- Greek yogurt is acidic, so it reacts with baking soda - this is what gives your baked goods their rise, but it starts working the moment they touch. Mix your wet ingredients (including the yogurt) separately from your dry ingredients, then combine them at the end so you don't lose that lift before the batter hits the oven.
- For frozen desserts, it's important to add some sugar to prevent the yogurt from getting so hard that it's hard to bite into.
drop us a note!